I share this past work with you to illustrate an
ecological fallacy. What might be generally true about executive directors (i.e., they are not subject matter experts), might not be true at the individual level.
Also, as with most epidemiological studies, we cannot rule out the role that
ecological fallacy may play where the population average may not be appropriate in estimating an individual's risk of mortality."
Although the authors state that there is no risk of a possible
ecological fallacy, it is obvious that most conclusions were obtained with data analysis of population-level records, which exceed individual conclusions (10).
He prefers his neologism to the more well-known "
ecological fallacy" because without this fallacy, "most epidemiologists, especially those employed by the government, would be out of a job." It is also richer than the
ecological fallacy because it occurs whenever an epidemiologist says "X causes Y" but never measures X.
To put it bluntly, this book falls in an
ecological fallacy that places the horse before the cart.
The general reader is taken 'behind the scenes' as it were, for a concise account of the necessity of geo-rectifying historic maps, an explanation of the dangers of the '
ecological fallacy' and a discussion of the decisions which must be made in order to produce a thematic (choropleth) map.
The
ecological fallacy and the gender ratio of suicide in China.
(2012) pointed out in their conclusion, there is a "possibility of an adverse effect of high fluoride exposure on children's neurodevelopment." Such a conclusion can be considered an
ecological fallacy, which can easily lead to mis interpretation of the results.
To avoid the
ecological fallacy, we restricted our inferences to the school level.
However, ecological studies have two major limitations: firstly, not all those who develop the disease of interest will necessarily have been exposed to the risk factor being investigated, which is called the
ecological fallacy; and secondly, confounding cannot always be taken into account, which can give misleading results.
The three major branches--continuous spatial variation, discrete spatial variation, and spatial point patterns--provide the core of the work, but other sections cover the history, spatio-temporal processes, and additional topics such as multi-variate spatial process models and spatial aggregation and the
ecological fallacy.
The criticisms are not new: Durkheim hypothesized a "suicidogenic current" that represented the society's "essence," he "drove a wedge between sociology and medical psychology," "elided the diversity of motives" in order to show that suicide is a social fact, "single-mindedly" dismissed case files, and failed to offer a "testable theory." Most importantly, Durkheim fell for the "
ecological fallacy," making assumptions about the "nature of individuals" based on the communities in which they lived, presuming that "all members of a group exhibit characteristics of that particular group at large" (p.