In this paper, I examine some methodological issues in Kennedy's stichometry and cast doubt on whether there is evidence to suppose a 12-part structure to Plato's works or any other basic stichometric claim.
A further problem in assessing Kennedy's stichometry is that it is not entirely clear which thesis or theses are being advanced.
The claim that stichometry confirms that our versions of Plato's texts are in good order, when it needs to assume that they are in good order to begin with, also looks distinctly circular.
Kennedy's application of stichometry to the pseudo-Platonic works, although interesting, does not prove a great deal.
As the Critias is unfinished, and we have no trace of the Hermocrates, the claim might then be that without being able to determine the length of the work, we cannot do the stichometry.
Surely Proclus, who wrote a very detailed commentary on the Timaeus and dealt with the musical aspects in great detail, would have something to say about stichometry and musical structure.
The lists of apocrypha from ancient sources, which James inserted in the body of his book (the Decretum Gelasianum, the seventh-century List of the Sixty Books, and the Stichometry
of Nicephorus), have been transposed to follow the Bibliography and modernized (pp.
The same practice is found in Athanasius and Rufinus, where Old and New Testament lists precede the combined list of antilegomena, and the disputed books of either Testament are designated |outside' or |ecclesiastical' books;(20) it appears in Epiphanius, who similarly lists Old and New Testament antilegomena after he has summarized the whole body of Old and New Testament scripture;(21) it is probably implied in Cyril of Jerusalem,(22) it is reflected in Jerome,(23) and it reappears later, for example, in the Stichometry