And the "intentional fallacy
" is an "intentional legitimacy."
Rather, if we apply the ideas of the literary theorist John Farrell (The Varieties of Authorial Intention: Literary Theory beyond the Intentional Fallacy
[Cham: Macmillan, 20171, esp.
It is nevertheless a valid and truthful statement which, be it said in passing, suggests that the prohibition of the so-called intentional fallacy
, which a couple of generations ago warned literary critics against examining an author's intentions (Wimsatt and Beardsley), was unwarranted.
Kelly's view that the omission of Curio, who is already absent from Shakespeare, is "designed to bring the Antony-icon closer to the paradigm" (65) comes close to being a kind of intentional fallacy
in service to ideology.
Despite drawing on McGrath's biographical background (setting hoary New Critical dogma aside, she recognizes how impossible it is to read McGrath without acknowledging, for example, the importance of his experience as the child of a superintending psychiatrist at Broadmoor) and his own critical views, Zlosnik manages to avoid falling prey to intentional fallacy
. She scrupulously balances McGrath's statements with her own interpretive convictions, which are marked by an evident familiarity with the (surprisingly sparse) critical literature on McGrath's fiction.
Literary critics WK Wimsatt and Monroe Beardsley famously argued in their book The Verbal Icon (1954) that it was a mistake (which they termed the "intentional fallacy
") to assume that a work is properly interpreted by knowing the intention of the author.
formalist focus on the text itself," which Kinderman sees as growing out of attempts to avoid "the socalled intentional fallacy
." The literary critics William Wimsatt and Monroe Beardsley famously argued in an article first published in 1946 that "...
She sidesteps the charge of "intentional fallacy
" (that we can know through a work of art what the author intended) by denying that her project is "a piece of literary criticism" (15); nevertheless, she asserts "that the narrative voice reflects something of the mind of the author" (15).
I tried, and repeatedly failed, to avoid the intentional fallacy
. I'd see a pattern that looked like Rothko, or Richter, or Miro, and think, "Ah, I get what he's doing there." But these weren't allusions; they were accidents.
An Expressionist interpretation of The War lapses immediately into intentional fallacy
, which in this case misconstrues Dix's biography.
Cheer as he brushes aside allegorical analysis of Tolkien (41) and literally responds "phooey" to critics of the so-called "intentional fallacy
Mazer observes that since the ascent of New Criticism, literary critics have designated the attempt to discern the author's original intention as the "intentional fallacy
." In contrast, stage-centered scholars want to understand what the dramatist envisioned.