This feedback helps the editor to decide the fate of the manuscript.8 Surprisingly the assessment of peer review
quality, standard and consistency is difficult because exact data of peer review
is not yet available.9,10 Moreover the study of peer review
is difficult and complex.9 The same manuscript receives different ratings by different peer reviewers evaluated through the same proforma resulting in low inter-rater reliability.11,12 Furthermore peer reviewers were found unable to point out all the errors in the manuscript.13 Since there is a growing need for systemic studies on peer review
,14 we plan that one aspect of peer review
assessment is to analyze the peer review
But our trad peer-reviewed publishing process is evolving, fast; completely new peer review
models are emerging.
Several jurisdictions have undergone or are undergoing the in-depth peer review
process, which is currently in its second round of reviews covering the period of April 2014 to March 2017.
HFMA's Peer Review
process provides healthcare financial managers with an objective, third-party evaluation of business solutions used in the healthcare workplace.
There are three types of peer review
reports: pass, pass with deficiency or fail.
Additionally, the entire peer-review process has been attacked in recent years because of several articles, replete with bad science, that managed to get through peer review
and were published in reputable journals.
has a long history with CPAs, as firm-on-firm peer review
has been a staple of quality assurance since the 1970s and continues as a mainstay in the profession's continual efforts to improve performance on audits and maintain the profession's reputation for rigor and trust.
All of us--authors, reviewers, editorial boards, and editors--have a responsibility to ensure quality through the peer review
process and the dissemination of scholarship.
* Can peer review
enhance writing rather than just focus on superficial errors?
The study analyzed the results of a radiation oncology-specific, peer review
survey conducted by ASTRO in 2013.
Cecile Bledsoe, R-Rogers, who wanted to prevent problems involving conflicts with hospitals and physicians peer review
committees, she said.